The History of our Building

Home
Banquet Menu
Ballroom Photos
History
Member Area
 
Available Banquet Dates
2008
2009
2010

 

Elisha Packer Wilbur Mansion

Elisha P. Wilbur – Born circa 1833 he was the son of a sea captain and his mother was the sister of Asa Packer.

The tower on the mansion’s north side was built possibly to permit Elisha to keep an eye on the passing trains of the Lehigh Valley Railroad and to be sure they were on time.

The game room was designed by a famous architect, Stanford White, who had an interesting history himself: He was the victim in one of the most celebrated murder cases in the early 20th century. (White was shot in New York’s Madison Square Garden by the jealous husband of a showgirl.)

One of the great mysteries of the mansion is who is buried in the old cemetery, now covered by the paved parking lot behind the mansion. Some say soldiers of the Continental Army. Some say no, they are buried beneath the nearby spur route. This is one mystery that may never be solved without an earthquake.

Elisha P. Wilbur went to school in Mauch Chunk (now Jim Thorpe). He left school when he was young and became a clerk in Uncle Asa Packer’s general stores. It appears that Uncle Asa saw in his nephew Elisha much more potential than what is usually associated with someone who sweeps floors and keeps the pickle barrel clean. Packer gave Wilbur a key role on the crew that surveyed the future route of Packer’s Lehigh Valley Railroad, and later became his personal Secretary. It was this later job, with its travel between Mauch Chunk and Philadelphia that introduced Wilbur to Bethlehem. The Christmas City must have impressed him as he settled here around 1857 and married Stella Abbot. This mansion was built in 1866-67 when Wilbur was only 33 years of age.

Obviously he was wealthy at the time and could have received help from his father, who may also have bought in with Asa Packer. Someone certainly advised him to invest money in coal and the railroads.

Wilbur and his wife raised seven children and the family was part of the city’s social elite, mingling with other local entrepreneurs such as Robert H. Sayre, who was involved with both the Railroad and the Bethlehem Iron Company. They kept to themselves thus little is known about them. Wilbur loved culture – he built the now gone Fountain Hill Opera House – and donated large amounts of money. Some of this philanthropy went toward the purchase of a new organ for the Church of the Nativity located on Wyandotte Street. Wilbur chose to build his brick mansion on Wyandotte Street, probably because of the proximity to the Railroad line, when asked how much it would cost to build today, some indicated millions. That appears to be a good ballpark figure. For example one would have to bring in an artist all the way from Italy to hand carve the teakwood in the library and dining room, just as Wilbur did. You would also have to purchase enough marble from which to build a fireplace for the living room and enough furniture for 18 really big rooms, including seven bedrooms and seven baths.

No records are available to learn how much money was spent to build the mansion, however the Masonic Society (then called the Masonic Building Corporation) bought the property in 1924 for $70,000. The purchase was a real bargain.